Choosing the Right Stanley Lunch Box for Work or Travel
By Stanley 1913 Drinkware & Gear | Bottles, Tumblers, Growlers ... | Published: 2026-10-23
Category: Buying Guides
Compare the All Day Midi Lunch Box and The Comeback Lunchbox to find the best insulated lunch box for your commute, picnic, or office routine.
Quick answer
For most commuters, the All Day Midi Lunch Box (6.3 QT) offers more capacity and strap convenience, while The Comeback Lunchbox (5.3 QT) suits those who want a classic shape with a built-in divider.
Capacity and shape matter for your routine
The All Day Midi Lunch Box holds 6.3 quarts — enough for a hearty lunch plus snacks or a side. Its rectangular shape stacks neatly inside a larger bag or the Legendary Useful Box. The Comeback Lunchbox is slightly smaller at 5.3 quarts but uses a classic rounded silhouette that some find more stylish. The trade-off: you lose about a quart of space, so it works best for standard lunches without extra containers.
Carry style affects daily ease
The All Day Midi Lunch Box comes with a strap, making it easy to sling over your shoulder for a walk to the office or a park picnic. The Comeback Lunchbox is designed to be carried by hand or worn, thanks to its crush-resistant molded EVA construction. If you frequently carry other bags, the strap on the All Day Midi frees up your hands. If you prefer a retro look and don't mind hand-carrying, the Comeback Lunchbox delivers that aesthetic.
Organization inside makes a difference
The Comeback Lunchbox features a built-in foldaway divider that keeps foods separate — useful for avoiding soggy sandwiches or mixing snacks. The All Day Midi Lunch Box does not include a divider, so you may need small containers or bags to separate items. If you like built-in organization, the Comeback Lunchbox wins. If you prefer to pack freely or use your own containers, the All Day Midi gives you a clean open space.
How to decide: three quick rules
- Rule 1: Match capacity to your meal size: If you pack a full meal plus fruit, yogurt, or a side, choose the 6.3 QT All Day Midi. For a standard sandwich-and-snack lunch, the 5.3 QT Comeback Lunchbox is enough.
- Rule 2: Choose your carry style: Need hands-free carrying? The All Day Midi with its included strap is your pick. Prefer a retro hand-carry or wear option? The Comeback Lunchbox works well.
- Rule 3: Decide on built-in organization: If you want a built-in foldaway divider to keep foods separate, go with The Comeback Lunchbox. If you prefer an open interior for flexible packing, the All Day Midi is better. Both lunchboxes are compatible with the Legendary Useful Box system for stacking.
At a glance: key product facts
- All Day Midi Lunch Box | 6.3 QT: Molded EVA insulation keeps lunch at the right temp for hours. You can pack a chilled salad or warm soup in the morning and it stays fresh until lunchtime without needing a microwave.
All Day Midi Lunch Box | 6.3 QT - The Comeback Lunchbox | 5.3 QT: Crush-resistant molded EVA construction that’s made to carry or wear. Dropping your bag or stuffing it into a crowded commuter backpack won't damage the lunchbox or its contents.
The Comeback Lunchbox | 5.3 QT
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Commuters who want a strap and extra capacity for a full lunch plus snacks
- Picnic-goers who need a roomy, easy-to-carry box that pairs with the Legendary Useful Box
Not ideal for
- Those who need built-in food separation without extra containers (choose The Comeback Lunchbox instead)
- Minimalist packers who prefer a smaller, classic-shaped lunchbox (choose The Comeback Lunchbox instead)
